Four for me
https://www.ratebeer.com/beer/trillium-permutation-series-30-double-ipa-with-galaxy/606578/344778/
https://www.ratebeer.com/beer/bad-martha-four-star-basil-saison/345052/344778/
https://www.ratebeer.com/beer/champlain-orchards-vermont-apple-cranberry-hard-cider/175360/344778/
https://www.ratebeer.com/beer/dunedin-midnight-sextant/293621/344778/
Okay then.
#23: Americas Rye Barrel Imperial Stout From the former Walter Payton’s Roundhouse that’s now part of Two Brothers. 6 ratings 4.5 2007
#46: Alter Alto Porto Porter This is a current beer, but still taproom only. I can’t help but admit I liked it. 6 ratings, 4.5 2016
#48: Flossmoor Station Ashmans Abbaye Dubbel From the Todd Ashman era. Very surprised so few people got to it, since it was at GABF. 9 ratings, 4.4 2003
#50: Rock Bottom Chicago Dillinger’s Demise Russian Imperial Stout Non-Barrel-Aged Somehow they put out a NON Barrel aged version of the better-received Dillinger’s Demise. That’s what they told me it was. And I seem to be the only one who had it. 1 rating, 4.4 2012
Another rock bottom in top 50. Wow. Never would have pegged those guys
6 for me that fit the question, all of which are either local to me now or local to a place I’ve lived, I assume this would explain the smaller # of ratings for these beers
https://www.ratebeer.com/beer/plan-bee-brush-hog/514673/87939/
https://www.ratebeer.com/beer/transmitter-h3-apricot-harvest-saison/362400/87939/
https://www.ratebeer.com/beer/brooklyn-local-11/151966/87939/
https://www.ratebeer.com/beer/other-half-citra-equinox/461358/87939/
https://www.ratebeer.com/beer/hardywood-second-anniversary-ale/235073/87939/
https://www.ratebeer.com/beer/magnify-flash-backs-are-forever/381805/87939/
Also had 1 that has exactly 10, so close but not quite in the described rules:
https://www.ratebeer.com/beer/melovino-nice-as-pie/323551/87939/
This Rock Bottom beer was by the brewmaster after Pete Crowley left to start Haymarket. And this was before the merger, when they still had names for their regular beers.
